| poeTV | Submit | Login   |

Reddit Digg Stumble Facebook

Help keep poeTV running


And please consider not blocking ads here. They help pay for the server. Pennies at a time. Literally.

Comment count is 17
infinite zest - 2015-01-03

Is that Sarah Brightman? I was a soprano in a Gregorian choir when I was a kid and we toured the world and we always thought these guys were pretty silly, but our director was incredibly strict. I always thought CHANT would be more fun..


infinite zest - 2015-01-03

Nothing says Christmas like Leonard Cohen..


That guy - 2015-01-03

I like the musical bits on sketch comedy shows plenty, but I was expecting more obvious jokes.


gravelstudios - 2015-01-03

I hate to be a wet towel, but this is not Gregorian Chant. It sounds kind of nice, and I guess I can understand why some people might like it, but it's not Gregorian Chant.


EvilHomer - 2015-01-03

It depends on what you mean by "Gregorian Chant" - the specific, academically-defined style of music? The broader, aesthetically-defined style of music? The famous choir itself?

This is a band called Gregorian.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregorian_%28band%29

Contrast with what most people think of when they hear the phrase "Gregorian chant", which is this album:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chant_%28Benedictine_Monks_of_Sa nto_Domingo_de_Silos_album%29

... both of which SUCK compared to the Mediaeval Baebes' Christmas. Discuss.


infinite zest - 2015-01-03

I guess it depends on your definition, kinda like if "EMO" is Rites of Spring or Fall Out Boy, or "METAL" as Amon Amarath or Metallica. Here's a link to the choir I used to be in:

http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/cantoresinecclesia


infinite zest - 2015-01-04

Interestingly, I just found out that they DO cover Metallica in their 1999 album.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masters_of_Chant

and that totally IS Sarah Brightman. Maybe Enigma were on to something!!! She hasn't aged a day since 1993.


gravelstudios - 2015-01-03

Sorry. I have a bachelor's degree in music, and sometimes I freak out about this kind of thing. For instance, it annoys me when people call anything that doesn't have electric guitars 'classical music'. I know they don't know what they're talking about and I should cut them some slack, but to me a term like 'classical' or 'Gregorian' has a very specific meaning. I didn't realize that this group is actually named 'Gregorian', so there's also that.
@i.z.: That's pretty good stuff. What voice part to you sing?


EvilHomer - 2015-01-03

Pffft, everyone knows that if the music doesn't have electric guitars, it's considered Country.


Cena_mark - 2015-01-03

Country is nothing but electric guitars. If the country artist uses acoustic guitars it becomes folk music.

Are these guys actually monks are are they posers in robes?


infinite zest - 2015-01-03

@gs I haven't sung with them since I was 12 years old. I used to be a boy soprano. For a while there we were considered #1 in the world, and sung for the only strictly Latin Church in North America, or at least west of the Mississippi. We sang at the Vatican and all sorts of other places in the world.

As far as Chant goes, I believe there was some controversy back when the first CD was released in the 90s, because they were all posers in robes but now I'm not sure if this is the same Chant (it was basically techno Gregorian chant) and the church called blasphemy on it.

As far as I go, I used the money from my chant experiences to buy wu tang clan tapes. They were also not official monks.


EvilHomer - 2015-01-04

Fake poser country, maybe. If you're one of these Dierks Bentley / Luke Bryan lovin' wannabe rock n' roll jits, sure alright whatever, but REAL country's gotta be made the way GOD intended.


EvilHomer - 2015-01-04

And no, they are not monks. I posted a link to their Wikipedia article above: according to that, they are mostly choir and session musicians. One of them is the wife of the dude who produced Enigma and Sarah Brightman. The monk thing is just for show.


fluffy - 2015-01-03

I didn't realize there was a turf war between multiple choirs crapping out annual albums that nobody wants.


Cena_mark - 2015-01-04

Housewives need music too.


Jet Bin Fever - 2015-01-03

Just awful!


TeenerTot - 2015-01-05

_\\
\*_/

It stinks!


Register or login To Post a Comment







Video content copyright the respective clip/station owners please see hosting site for more information.
Privacy Statement